Cover of If These Are Men

If These Are Men…

The Doctors of Struthof

by Serge Janouin-Benanti

Translated by Eva N. Siskowski Boatwright

“If these are men, I am the worst kind of filth!” Professor of medicine August Hirt’s introspection, provoked by the fear of soon being captured by French troops, only lasted a few moments. His Gypsy test subjects couldn’t have been men, you don’t do that to men…

If Jews were men, nobody would forgive him for the creation of his precious collection of skulls. He’d had to proceed with urgency, Himmler had confided to him that soon there wouldn’t be a single living Jew left in Europe! He had responded as a scientist, he had selected the subjects that were the most representative of the race, according to Mein Kampf, had measured them from every angle, photographed them, before gassing them to reduce them to skeletons…

Serge Janouin-Benanti takes us to the Natzweiler-Struthof concentration camp in Alsace. He not only reveals to us the experiments of August Hirt, but also those of two other distinguished professors from the School of Medicine in Strasbourg: the virologist and nominee for the Nobel Prize, Eugen Haagen, as well as the hospital director, Otto Bickenbach.

This harrowing tale will leave you speechless. You will be immersed in the abominable inner workings of racist rationale as events unfold. An unforgettable book.

Some pictures from the photo album

Pr August Hirt

Pr August Hirt

Pr Otto Bickenbac

Pr Otto Bickenbac

Pr Eugen Haagen

Pr Eugen Haagen

Bruno Beger measuring the nose of a Tibetan

Bruno Beger measuring
the nose of a Tibetan

Dr Karl Brandt

Dr Karl Brandt

Where to buy the book:

Reviews

“‘Isn’t it dangerous to test a vaccine that’s still in the experimental phase on human beings, even if they are detainees?’

‘They aren’t detainees, just Poles. And Poles aren’t human beings,’ Dr. Gräfe snapped.”

I cannot emphasize enough the significance of this work, which contains a handbook of images, at a time when the values of humanism are disappearing, and when the voices of racists and Holocaust-deniers are growing louder and louder.”

Les lectures de l'oncle Paul, Paul Maugendre, April 23, 2012

Serge Janouin-Benanti organizes the story into three interlocking portraits, each centered on a real doctor whose career converged at Struthof: Eugen Haagen, August Hirt, and Otto Bickenbach. The table of contents telegraphs their arcs with bitter irony: “Ready to Do It All Again,” “If these are men, I am the worst kind of filth,” and “It All Depends on the Value of the Race.”

The marina books lovers, September 2025

“If These Are Men… – The Doctors of Struthof is the true-crime thriller history forgot to package as a page-turner. Three star physicians. One hidden laboratory. Zero conscience.”

Le journal du Gu, January 2017

“A university glitters; a camp smokes. Between them, a door opens, and medicine walks through. Based on true events, If These Are Men…, The Doctors of Struthof, follows three renowned physicians who turned Natzweiler-Struthof into a laboratory. Fever charts, skull measurements, timed gassings: procedure becomes murder. Told with thriller pace and documentary rigor, this book restores names, and shatters complacency. Read it and refuse to look away.”

CDL 44, October 2016

“The door between campus and camp. During the German occupation, the University of Strasbourg was reconstituted under the Reich just a short drive from the concentration camp of Natzweiler-Struthof. That proximity became opportunity…”

Logbook of readings aboard Foxy, July 2017

“Most atrocities are not spontaneous. They’re scheduled. In If These Are Men… – The Doctors of Struthof, the engine of harm is not a single mad scientist but a system: budgets, signatures, supply lists, and minutes from meetings. Understanding that machinery is the point of the book, and the value of revisiting it now.”

Blog 3E éditions

By the same author: